Thursday, December 21, 2017

The Cultural Dilemma in Bhutan: Self Reflection


Disclaimer: I am neither cultural experts nor good writer; thus, I would like to inform the readers that the views, thoughts and opinions expressed in the text are not meant to go against any one. I have just written to short answer the question on “What is an urgent challenge in my country?”. Forgive me if my answer is wrong.

Photo: www.google.bt
Bhutan being sandwiched between two most populous nations in the world, her survival as an independent nation rests on its unique cultural identity.  Cultural identity is Bhutan’s shield against the negative and disrupting influences of modernization and globalization in absent of military might and economic power. Cultural is dynamic, thus, Bhutan’s cultural landscape is changing at an unprecedented pace. Yet, some of us ask what really constitute in Bhutanese cultural identity. And only few people are bothered about the changing cultures in the society and nation as a whole. The traditional animistic and Buddhist belief systems are now being replaced by modern scientific knowledge. Change is very prominent mostly in the urban areas, both in the form of tangible objects and intangible behaviors and beliefs. Therefore, Bhutan is at crossword of traditional and modern world. Do people of Bhutan know what really constitutes in the Bhutan cultural identity? Is Bhutanese adapting the modernization in right direction? What kind of Bhutan can one envisage in future in terms of cultural identity? The above embedded questions are still lingering in mind of people and globalization is in their own fast pace around the globe.

Bhutan’s cultural discourse cannot conclude only around the religious beliefs and celebrations. There are more to be considered; how we think, how we speak, how we dress and how we interact with people around you. Although, the current pace of changes in cultural identity are very fast but few people are bothered about declining the unique attributes of Bhutanese identity. Other than citizenship, people do share many similar salient features related to cultural and sovereignty. Most of people have knowledge deficiency in what constitute in Bhutanese cultural identity. And on other hand, people think of cultural distinction from others before knowing of Bhutan’s cultural heritage. Traditional cultures are mostly equated with life style of monastic life and some agency that are responsible for preservation of cultures. It is also perceived as the life of past days.  How can Bhutanese people contribute in construction of cultural identity when we can’t distinct from others?

Photo: www.google.bt
Bhutan is called by last sangrila in the region. The holistic approach, Gross National Happiness (GNH) is figured as developmental instrument in Bhutan. The country always seeks to balance between material development with spiritual wellbeing and modernity with tradition. And Bhutan is well known as the country who takes very serious about the caring of the traditional cultures.  Cultural Preservation is one of the four pillars of GNH and leaders and government of the day is aware of it. Yet, in other side, Bhutan’s cultural landscape is changing at unparalleled pace. The intense changes are seen today in the urban area obviously in street of Thimphu (capital of Bhutan) and Phuntsholing (one of the business hubs in Bhutan). In some case, one can see disappearance of traditional cultures because of its adaptation, alteration due to westernization and modernization. Let’s take living style of Bhutanese people today; a very few restaurant of Bhutanese traditional cuisines, more of the fast-food restaurants, most Bhutanese men and women love to wear other fashion dresses than national dress. National dresses are wearing only in offices and other special occasion. People are comfortable in communicating in English and other foreign dialects than national language. Most of the Bhutanese languages are in verge of extinction.  Almost half of the audiences in some local festivals are tourists. The examples will go on listing. Thus, the results of acculturation and McDonaldization of society are seen widely in the nation.


With rapid advancement in technology and lifestyle, preserving the unique cultures and traditions has become herculean task. Bhutan is also no exception. As cultural identity is made up of the myriad attributes like beliefs, food habits, dresses and other daily activities, Bhutan should also give regard on numerous parameters of modernization too. For instance, Youth are in commotion in accepting the tradition cultures and modern fashions. That raises the question of how Bhutanese cultural is affordable and attractive to present youth.
Photo: website 
And how many of us know the art of Bhutanese painting and sculpturing, how can we save spoken languages which are at verge of extinctions? What will be Bhutanese uniqueness in future? Bhutanese people are in cross puzzle nodal of not knowing the traditional culture and modern fashion. The experts in cultures have to intrude in the play field before it is late. Let us learn from past and pass to future. lets not regret. let us learn from neighboring nations. Although, there are many challenges around us, we are hopeful that blessings from the pursuit of Gross National Happiness will save us from losing our rich cultural.  Long Live our Monarchs. 
           Tashi Delek.
                                                                                           
   ---------------Geden----------------

         geden.oiiwaii@gmail.com